A look at the state primary results

There were ousted incumbents, some real nail-biters, and a slate of new name winners for open seats

Brent Benson
2024-09-14

While much went as expected in the September 3, 2024 state primary elections there were some notable losses to incumbents and some close incumbent victories while the open seat wins pave the way for a new set of leaders in the state legislature and Governor’s Council.

Incumbent losses

It is very difficult to challenge and defeat a sitting state legislator or Governor’s Council member from within the same party, but three incumbents lost in September 3 Democratic primaries.

Governor’s Council - Third
Incumbent Marilyn M. Petitto Devaney (D-Watertown) - Dolan was able to achieve a 4 point victory over 25-year incumbent Devaney
Winner Mara Dolan (D-Concord) 46,250 +3,670 +4%
Incumbent Marilyn M. Petitto Devaney (D-Watertown) 42,580

Current Governor's Councillor; Candidate for Re-nomination
State Representative - Second Plymouth
Incumbent Susan Williams-Gifford (R-Wareham) - Jim Lyons and Trump acolyte Gaskey was able to defeat moderate Gifford in an 18 point victory. There is no Democrat on the ballot in November.
Winner John Robert Gaskey (R-Carver) 1,811 +553 +18%
Incumbent Susan Williams-Gifford (R-Wareham) 1,258

Candidate for Re-nomination
State Representative - Eighteenth Middlesex
Incumbent Rady Mom (D-Lowell) - Hong won by 181 votes over incumbent Rady Mom who had prevailed by 56 votes over Hong in 2022.
Winner Tara Hong (D-Lowell) 1,191 +181 +7%
Incumbent Rady Mom (D-Lowell) 1,010

Current State Representative
Andrew W. Kollar (D-Lowell) 313


Close incumbent wins

There were five races for State Representative where the incumbent victory was probably closer than they would have hoped, including a 41 vote recount win for Representative Marjorie Decker after challenger Evan Mackay had declared victory on election night.

State Representative - Twenty-Fifth Middlesex
Incumbent Marjorie C. Decker (D-Cambridge) - Mackay declared victory on election night before all of the votes were counted. Decker eeked out a 41 vote win after a recount.
Incumbent Winner Marjorie C. Decker (D-Cambridge) 3,472 +41 +1% Current State Representative
Evan Mackay (D-Cambridge) 3,431


State Representative - Eleventh Hampden
Incumbent Bud L. Williams (D-Springfield) - McKnight came surprisingly close to unseating Williams by raising distinctions on reproductive rights.
Incumbent Winner Bud L. Williams (D-Springfield) 1,768 +245 +7%
Johnnie Rs Mcknight (D-Springfield) 1,523


State Representative - Ninth Middlesex
Incumbent Thomas M. Stanley (D-Waltham) - May, Chair of the Waltham Dem. City Committee, came within 710 votes of 12-term incumbent Stanley’s vote total.
Incumbent Winner Thomas M. Stanley (D-Waltham) 2,748 +710 +15% Candidate for Re-nomination
Heather A. May (D-Waltham) 2,038


State Representative - Sixteenth Essex
Incumbent Francisco E. Paulino (D-Methuen) - Paulino increased his 2022 margin of 161 votes to 499 votes over former State Rep Devers.
Incumbent Winner Francisco E. Paulino (D-Methuen) 1,581 +499 +19% Current State Representative
Marcos A. Devers (D-Lawrence) 1,082

Former State Representative, Mayor, Council President
State Representative - Thirty-Fifth Middlesex
Incumbent Paul J. Donato (D-Medford) - Mossalam lost to incumbent Donato by only 50 votes in 2022 but Donato increased his margin to over 1,000 votes in 2024
Incumbent Winner Paul J. Donato (D-Medford) 3,278 +1,141 +19% Candidate for Re-nomination
Nichole Dawn Mossalam (D-Malden) 2,137


Zayda Ortiz (D-Malden) 583


Open seat winners

There will be new faces in the Governor’s Council and state legislatures from this round of primary winners.

Governor’s Council - Second
Incumbent Robert L. Jubinville (D-Milton) - was appointed as Clerk Magistrate of Framingham District Court
Winner Tamisha L. Civil (D-Stoughton) 27,702 +11,700 +16% Current Town Meeting Member
Sean Murphy (D-Bridgewater) 16,002

Veteran
Muriel Elaine Kramer (D-Hopkinton) 15,767

Former Hopkinton Selectboard Member; Veteran
David S. Reservitz (D-Needham) 11,975


State Senate - Third Bristol and Plymouth
Incumbent Marc R. Pacheco (D-Taunton) - is working on the new Transatlantic Climate Alliance
Winner Joseph Richard Pacheco (D-Raynham) 7,779 +2,846 +22%
Barry Christopher Sanders (D-Taunton) 4,933

Taunton City Councilor
State Senate - Norfolk, Plymouth and Bristol
Incumbent Walter F. Timilty, Jr. (D-Milton) - is running for Norfolk County Clerk of Courts
Winner William J. Driscoll, Jr. (D-Milton) 7,425 +2,092 +13% Current State Representative
Erin G. Bradley (D-Milton) 5,333

Current Select Board Member, Milton
Kathleen Crogan-Camara (D-Randolph) 3,654


State Senate - Plymouth and Barnstable
Incumbent Susan Lynn Moran (D-Falmouth) - is running for Barnstable County Clerk of Courts
Winner Mathew J. Muratore (R-Plymouth) 7,010 +45 +0%
Kari Macrae (R-Bourne) 6,965

Current School Committee Member
State Representative - Eleventh Middlesex
Incumbent Kay S. Khan (D-Newton) - is retiring
Winner Amy Mah Sangiolo (D-Newton) 5,181 +4,117 +66% Former City Councilor
Alexander Jablon (D-Newton) 1,064


State Representative - Third Berkshire
Incumbent William “Smitty” Pignatelli (D-Lenox) - is retiring
Winner Leigh Susan Davis (D-Great Barrington) 4,048 +1,335 +18% Great Barrington Selectboard Member
Patrick Thomas White (D-Stockbridge) 2,713

Select Board Member
Jamie M. Minacci (D-Stockbridge) 474

Current Select Board Member
State Representative - Barnstable, Dukes and Nantucket
Incumbent Dylan A. Fernandes (D-Falmouth) - is running for the Plymouth and Barnstable State Senate seat
Winner Thomas W. Moakley (D-Falmouth) 3,523 +784 +13% Former Cape and Islands Assistant District Attorney
Arielle Reid Faria (D-West Tisbury) 2,739


State Representative - Twelfth Middlesex
Incumbent Ruth B. Balser (D-Newton) - is retiring
Winner Greg Schwartz (D-Newton) 3,424 +815 +10% Former Newton City Councilor at-Large
Bill Humphrey (D-Newton) 2,609

City Councilor
Rick Lipof (D-Newton) 2,543

Current Newton City Councilor at-Large
State Representative - Thirteenth Norfolk
Incumbent Denise C. Garlick (D-Needham) - is retiring
Winner Joshua Tarsky (D-Needham) 2,742 +694 +13% Veteran
Patrick A. Gatto (D-Needham) 2,048


Kenneth J. Ruetenik (D-Needham) 577


State Representative - First Plymouth
Incumbent Mathew J. Muratore (R-Plymouth) - is not running
Winner Michelle L. Badger (D-Plymouth) 2,621 +510 +8%
Winner Jesse G. Brown (R-Plymouth) 2,241 +214 +5% Veteran
Arthur Thomas Desloges (D-Plymouth) 2,111

Town Meeting Member
Dee Wallace Spencer (R-Plymouth) 2,027

Former Town Meeting Member
Stephen Michael Palmer (D-Plymouth) 951

Plymouth Redevelopment Authority Commissioner
Scott Francis Hokanson, Sr. (D-Plymouth) 545


State Representative - Seventh Norfolk
Incumbent William J. Driscoll, Jr (D-Milton) - is running for the Norfolk, Plymouth and Bristol State Senate seat
Winner Richard Gerard Wells, Jr. (D-Milton) 2,307 +250 +4% Current Member, Milton Select Board
Christos Alexopoulos (D-Randolph) 2,057

Randolph Town Councilor
Tony King (D-Milton) 2,034


State Representative - Tenth Bristol
Incumbent William M. Straus (D-Mattapoisett) - is not running
Winner Joseph M. Pires (R-Rochester) 1,894 +1,040 +38% Current School Committee Member
Robert S. Mcconnell (R-Fairhaven) 854

Fairhaven Town Meeting Member
State Representative - Sixth Plymouth
Incumbent Josh S. Cutler (D-Duxbury) - has been named Undersecretary of Apprenticeship, Work-Based Learning, and Policy by Governor Healey
Winner Kenneth Peter Sweezey (R-Pembroke) 1,846 +165 +5%
Jane L. Cournan (R-Pembroke) 1,681


State Representative - Eleventh Essex
Incumbent Peter L. Capano (D-Lynn) - is not running
Winner Sean Reid (D-Lynn) 1,778 +270 +8% Current School Committee Member
Hong L. Net (D-Lynn) 1,508

Current City Councilor
State Representative - First Bristol
Incumbent Fred Jay Barrows (R-Mansfield) - is retiring
Winner Kostas Loukos (D-Mansfield) 1,670 +441 +12% Former Town Moderator
David R. Martin (D-Mansfield) 1,229


Michael E. Toole (D-Norton) 679

Board of Assessors Member; Former Select Board Member

Full results

U.S. Senate

Senator in Congress - Statewide
Incumbent Elizabeth Ann Warren (D-Cambridge) - Cryptocurrency advocate Dean has had the highest profile and done the most fundraising, followed by Cain, while Antonellis has not made much of an effort
Winner John Deaton (R-Swansea) 136,773 +81,833 +39% Veteran; Former Special Assistant United States Attorney
Robert J. Antonellis (R-Medford) 54,940


Ian Cain (R-Quincy) 19,374

Current Quincy City Councilor

U.S. Congress

Representative in Congress - Eighth
Incumbent Stephen F. Lynch (D-Boston) - Only Gavatsos has done any fundraising or campaigning for this primary
Winner Robert G. Burke (R-Dedham) 10,335 +4,119 +18%
James M. Govatsos (R-Walpole) 6,216


Daniel Kelly (R-Boston) 5,761


Governor’s Council

Governor’s Council - Third
Incumbent Marilyn M. Petitto Devaney (D-Watertown) - Dolan was able to achieve a 4 point victory over 25-year incumbent Devaney
Winner Mara Dolan (D-Concord) 46,250 +3,670 +4%
Incumbent Marilyn M. Petitto Devaney (D-Watertown) 42,580

Current Governor's Councillor; Candidate for Re-nomination
Governor’s Council - Fourth
Incumbent Christopher A. Iannella, Jr. (D-Boston) - 30-year Brockton incumbent Iannella faces two challengers but has a sizeable fundraising advantage
Incumbent Winner Christopher A. Iannella, Jr. (D-Boston) 41,849 +17,965 +24% Present Governor's Councillor
Stacey K. Borden (D-Boston) 23,884


Ronald Primo Iacobucci (D-Quincy) 8,283


Governor’s Council - Second
Incumbent Robert L. Jubinville (D-Milton) - was appointed as Clerk Magistrate of Framingham District Court
Winner Tamisha L. Civil (D-Stoughton) 27,702 +11,700 +16% Current Town Meeting Member
Sean Murphy (D-Bridgewater) 16,002

Veteran
Muriel Elaine Kramer (D-Hopkinton) 15,767

Former Hopkinton Selectboard Member; Veteran
David S. Reservitz (D-Needham) 11,975


State Senate

State Senate - First Suffolk
Incumbent Nicholas P. Collins (D-Boston) - Community Organizer Skeens has raised a little over $1,000 in his bid to oust Collins
Incumbent Winner Nicholas P. Collins (D-Boston) 10,386 +7,594 +58% Current State Senator
Juwan Khiry Skeens (D-Boston) 2,792


State Senate - Second Bristol and Plymouth
Incumbent Mark C. Montigny (D-New Bedford) - Montigny has a campaign account with over $700K while challenger Kivi has not raised or spent campaign money
Incumbent Winner Mark C. Montigny (D-New Bedford) 8,616 +6,490 +60% Candidate for Re-nomination; Current State Senator
Molly Kivi (D-New Bedford) 2,126


State Senate - Third Bristol and Plymouth
Incumbent Marc R. Pacheco (D-Taunton) - is working on the new Transatlantic Climate Alliance
Winner Joseph Richard Pacheco (D-Raynham) 7,779 +2,846 +22%
Barry Christopher Sanders (D-Taunton) 4,933

Taunton City Councilor
State Senate - Norfolk, Plymouth and Bristol
Incumbent Walter F. Timilty, Jr. (D-Milton) - is running for Norfolk County Clerk of Courts
Winner William J. Driscoll, Jr. (D-Milton) 7,425 +2,092 +13% Current State Representative
Erin G. Bradley (D-Milton) 5,333

Current Select Board Member, Milton
Kathleen Crogan-Camara (D-Randolph) 3,654


State Senate - Hampden
Incumbent Adam Gomez (D-Springfield) - Two-term incumbent Gomez is being challenged by city councilor and Rep. Bud Williams aide Malo Brown
Incumbent Winner Adam Gomez (D-Springfield) 7,326 +4,315 +42% Candidate for Re-nomination; State Senator
Malo L. Brown (D-Springfield) 3,011

Current City Councilor
State Senate - Plymouth and Barnstable
Incumbent Susan Lynn Moran (D-Falmouth) - is running for Barnstable County Clerk of Courts
Winner Mathew J. Muratore (R-Plymouth) 7,010 +45 +0%
Kari Macrae (R-Bourne) 6,965

Current School Committee Member

State Representative

State Representative - Twenty-Seventh Middlesex
Incumbent Erika Uyterhoeven (D-Somerville) - One of two progressive Cambridge lawmakers facing a challenge from the left
Incumbent Winner Erika Uyterhoeven (D-Somerville) 5,787 +3,181 +38% Candidate for Re-nomination
Kathleen M. Hornby (D-Somerville) 2,606


State Representative - Eleventh Middlesex
Incumbent Kay S. Khan (D-Newton) - is retiring
Winner Amy Mah Sangiolo (D-Newton) 5,181 +4,117 +66% Former City Councilor
Alexander Jablon (D-Newton) 1,064


State Representative - Seventh Middlesex
Incumbent Jack Patrick Lewis (D-Framingham) - First-time candidate Phelps hopes to unseat 4-term incumbent Lewis
Incumbent Winner Jack Patrick Lewis (D-Framingham) 4,527 +3,624 +67% Candidate for Re-nomination; Current State Representative
Carlton I. Phelps, Jr. (D-Ashland) 903


State Representative - Third Berkshire
Incumbent William “Smitty” Pignatelli (D-Lenox) - is retiring
Winner Leigh Susan Davis (D-Great Barrington) 4,048 +1,335 +18% Great Barrington Selectboard Member
Patrick Thomas White (D-Stockbridge) 2,713

Select Board Member
Jamie M. Minacci (D-Stockbridge) 474

Current Select Board Member
State Representative - Fifth Middlesex
Incumbent David Paul Linsky (D-Natick) - Jaymin Patel ran and lost against incumbent Linsky in the 2020 primary
Incumbent Winner David Paul Linsky (D-Natick) 4,047 +2,526 +45% Candidate for Re-nomination; Former Assistant District Attorney
Jaymin A. Patel (D-Natick) 1,521


State Representative - Barnstable, Dukes and Nantucket
Incumbent Dylan A. Fernandes (D-Falmouth) - is running for the Plymouth and Barnstable State Senate seat
Winner Thomas W. Moakley (D-Falmouth) 3,523 +784 +13% Former Cape and Islands Assistant District Attorney
Arielle Reid Faria (D-West Tisbury) 2,739


State Representative - Twenty-Fifth Middlesex
Incumbent Marjorie C. Decker (D-Cambridge) - Mackay declared victory on election night before all of the votes were counted. Decker eeked out a 41 vote win after a recount.
Incumbent Winner Marjorie C. Decker (D-Cambridge) 3,472 +41 +1% Current State Representative
Evan Mackay (D-Cambridge) 3,431


State Representative - Twelfth Middlesex
Incumbent Ruth B. Balser (D-Newton) - is retiring
Winner Greg Schwartz (D-Newton) 3,424 +815 +10% Former Newton City Councilor at-Large
Bill Humphrey (D-Newton) 2,609

City Councilor
Rick Lipof (D-Newton) 2,543

Current Newton City Councilor at-Large
State Representative - Thirty-Fifth Middlesex
Incumbent Paul J. Donato (D-Medford) - Mossalam lost to incumbent Donato by only 50 votes in 2022 but Donato increased his margin to over 1,000 votes in 2024
Incumbent Winner Paul J. Donato (D-Medford) 3,278 +1,141 +19% Candidate for Re-nomination
Nichole Dawn Mossalam (D-Malden) 2,137


Zayda Ortiz (D-Malden) 583


State Representative - Ninth Middlesex
Incumbent Thomas M. Stanley (D-Waltham) - May, Chair of the Waltham Dem. City Committee, came within 710 votes of 12-term incumbent Stanley’s vote total.
Incumbent Winner Thomas M. Stanley (D-Waltham) 2,748 +710 +15% Candidate for Re-nomination
Heather A. May (D-Waltham) 2,038


State Representative - Thirteenth Norfolk
Incumbent Denise C. Garlick (D-Needham) - is retiring
Winner Joshua Tarsky (D-Needham) 2,742 +694 +13% Veteran
Patrick A. Gatto (D-Needham) 2,048


Kenneth J. Ruetenik (D-Needham) 577


State Representative - First Plymouth
Incumbent Mathew J. Muratore (R-Plymouth) - is not running
Winner Michelle L. Badger (D-Plymouth) 2,621 +510 +8%
Winner Jesse G. Brown (R-Plymouth) 2,241 +214 +5% Veteran
Arthur Thomas Desloges (D-Plymouth) 2,111

Town Meeting Member
Dee Wallace Spencer (R-Plymouth) 2,027

Former Town Meeting Member
Stephen Michael Palmer (D-Plymouth) 951

Plymouth Redevelopment Authority Commissioner
Scott Francis Hokanson, Sr. (D-Plymouth) 545


State Representative - Eighth Suffolk
Incumbent Jay D. Livingstone (D-Boston) - Graf is running an issue candidacy on a disability bil sent to study by a committee Livingstone chairs;, Linardin has run for State Rep and City Council before
Incumbent Winner Jay D. Livingstone (D-Boston) 2,532 +2,067 +67% Current State Representative
Lisa Jeanne Graf (D-Boston) 465


Kelechi Linardon (D-Boston) 66


State Representative - Seventh Norfolk
Incumbent William J. Driscoll, Jr (D-Milton) - is running for the Norfolk, Plymouth and Bristol State Senate seat
Winner Richard Gerard Wells, Jr. (D-Milton) 2,307 +250 +4% Current Member, Milton Select Board
Christos Alexopoulos (D-Randolph) 2,057

Randolph Town Councilor
Tony King (D-Milton) 2,034


State Representative - Sixth Suffolk
Incumbent Russell E. Holmes (D-Boston) - Previous challenger Hardaway is joined by Adams and previous Nick Collins challenger Pierce
Incumbent Winner Russell E. Holmes (D-Boston) 2,254 +1,604 +52% Current State Representative
Haris H. Hardaway (D-Boston) 650


Samuel Pierce (D-Boston) 193


State Representative - Seventh Worcester
Incumbent Paul K. Frost (R-Auburn) - Frigon is know for advocacy against vaccine mandates
Incumbent Winner Paul K. Frost (R-Auburn) 2,107 +1,631 +63% Candidate for Re-nomination
Michelle L. Frigon (R-Millbury) 476


State Representative - Tenth Bristol
Incumbent William M. Straus (D-Mattapoisett) - is not running
Winner Joseph M. Pires (R-Rochester) 1,894 +1,040 +38% Current School Committee Member
Robert S. Mcconnell (R-Fairhaven) 854

Fairhaven Town Meeting Member
State Representative - Sixth Plymouth
Incumbent Josh S. Cutler (D-Duxbury) - has been named Undersecretary of Apprenticeship, Work-Based Learning, and Policy by Governor Healey
Winner Kenneth Peter Sweezey (R-Pembroke) 1,846 +165 +5%
Jane L. Cournan (R-Pembroke) 1,681


State Representative - Second Plymouth
Incumbent Susan Williams-Gifford (R-Wareham) - Jim Lyons and Trump acolyte Gaskey was able to defeat moderate Gifford in an 18 point victory. There is no Democrat on the ballot in November.
Winner John Robert Gaskey (R-Carver) 1,811 +553 +18%
Incumbent Susan Williams-Gifford (R-Wareham) 1,258

Candidate for Re-nomination
State Representative - Eleventh Essex
Incumbent Peter L. Capano (D-Lynn) - is not running
Winner Sean Reid (D-Lynn) 1,778 +270 +8% Current School Committee Member
Hong L. Net (D-Lynn) 1,508

Current City Councilor
State Representative - Eleventh Hampden
Incumbent Bud L. Williams (D-Springfield) - McKnight came surprisingly close to unseating Williams by raising distinctions on reproductive rights.
Incumbent Winner Bud L. Williams (D-Springfield) 1,768 +245 +7%
Johnnie Rs Mcknight (D-Springfield) 1,523


State Representative - Eleventh Plymouth
Incumbent Rita A. Mendes (D-Brockton) - Fontaine ran as an Unenrolled candidate in the last 2022 general election won by Mendes, now challenging in the Dem. Primary
Incumbent Winner Rita A. Mendes (D-Brockton) 1,709 +1,249 +58% Current State Representative; Former Councilor at-Large
Fred Fontaine (D-Brockton) 460


State Representative - First Bristol
Incumbent Fred Jay Barrows (R-Mansfield) - is retiring
Winner Kostas Loukos (D-Mansfield) 1,670 +441 +12% Former Town Moderator
David R. Martin (D-Mansfield) 1,229


Michael E. Toole (D-Norton) 679

Board of Assessors Member; Former Select Board Member
State Representative - Sixteenth Essex
Incumbent Francisco E. Paulino (D-Methuen) - Paulino increased his 2022 margin of 161 votes to 499 votes over former State Rep Devers.
Incumbent Winner Francisco E. Paulino (D-Methuen) 1,581 +499 +19% Current State Representative
Marcos A. Devers (D-Lawrence) 1,082

Former State Representative, Mayor, Council President
State Representative - Twenty-Eighth Middlesex
Incumbent Joseph W. Mcgonagle (D-Everett) - City Councilor Marchese lost in a similar challenge in 2022, also 1998 and 1990
Incumbent Winner Joseph W. Mcgonagle (D-Everett) 1,493 +774 +35% Current State Representative
Michael K. Marchese (D-Everett) 719


State Representative - Eighteenth Middlesex
Incumbent Rady Mom (D-Lowell) - Hong won by 181 votes over incumbent Rady Mom who had prevailed by 56 votes over Hong in 2022.
Winner Tara Hong (D-Lowell) 1,191 +181 +7%
Incumbent Rady Mom (D-Lowell) 1,010

Current State Representative
Andrew W. Kollar (D-Lowell) 313